Most mornings at our house start in virtually identical form. Sometime between about 5:30 and 6:30 a.m., I am awakened by the voice of my 4-year-old, Elizabeth, shouting “MOMMY WHEN WILL MY LIGHT TURN GREEN?!” Eyes suddenly wide open, I sluggishly reach over for the video monitor that sits on my nightstand and see the face of my petite daughter. Actually, I see only her nose and mouth pushed up against the camera that sits on the book shelf in her room. “Not for another hour, Elizabeth. Go back to sleep,” I say grumpily into the monitor. Most of the time I don’t even know exactly what time it is, but I know from experience and the darkness out my window that it is definitely not time for her to get up. The green light to which she is referring is an alarm clock that looks like a stop light. The light is red during the night and turns green in the morning when she is allowed to get up. Recommended to us by our pediatrician, this is our most recent attempt at getting Elizabeth not to awaken the entire household way before a civilized time. I could write a book about the poor sleep habits that led to the purchase of this helpful clock, but I will have to save that story for another post. This game of red light, green light continues every ten minutes or so (Elizabeth playing noisily in her room all the while), until the stop light finally turns green at 7 a.m. and she immediately informs me that the light has given her permission to come out of her room. Start your engines. Our daily race is on.
Seconds after letting Elizabeth out of her room (our pediatrician also recommended a baby gate in her door), the requests begin. “Can I have some juice?” “Snack please.” “Put on a show.” “Let’s color!” After meeting most of her demands and successfully putting off coloring until a later hour, I grab a cup of coffee and attempt to “hatch,” as my mother-in-law says. I don’t possess the early bird blood that Elizabeth most definitely inherited from her Daddy, who wakes up for work at 3 a.m. six days a week. I need a little time to slowly awaken before playing Go Fish, sculpting Play-Doh or pretending to be the evil queen from Snow White. When 8:00 rolls around, Caroline, my Sleeping Beauty, also begins to hatch. After several cuddly, wonderful minutes, then I know it is coming; the point in our daily routine that I dread, because it almost always results in tears, tantrums and time-outs. That’s right, it’s time to get dressed.
Elizabeth announces her desire to put on her clothes and runs to her room. Most often, she returns with an outfit that does not exactly look like something you’d find on the mannequin at Baby Gap. Individually, they are each very cute pieces of clothing that we are very lucky to own, but together they are, well, “very colorful” (read: a mismatched mess.) Her favorite combination lately is her red leggings with black bows that her grandma bought her to go with her Christmas dress, paired with her pink and purple flower dress, a red headband with a bow that I made her, purple socks and her red “sparkly shoes”. I think she likes this outfit because it includes all of her favorite colors. I start out trying to be very positive and say, “Oh, that’s a colorful outfit! Very nice choice. Usually we try to match our pants with our dress though. How about if we look for a purple or pink pair of pants?” She begins getting upset. “NO! I like these pants,” she says. She loses control of her emotions very quickly and begins crying and yelling. “I want to wear this dress and these pants,” she says as she runs off to her room and slams the door. I’m not sure why I care so much what my children wear. Will the kids in her preschool class make fun of her or not want to play with her? No. In fact the kids at school probably think she looks as fabulous as she thinks she looks. Perhaps the other parents I bump into at drop off will wonder why I don’t have more control over my child and question my parenting skills. That is probably not the case as I am certain they each experience their own struggles, although I am known to care a little too much about what people think. Am I that “anal” that I have to ensure everything is matching and orderly? Well, maybe a little bit. Are social pressures to dress my child nicely that strong? Maybe, but I don’t care about that so much. I have always been pretty practical about dressing my children and myself. The majority of their clothes come from Target, outlet stores or Old Navy. A lot of it may have to do with my desire to not let them get their way too often. Over the past few years I think Andy and I have developed a parenting style in which we emphasize respect for others, especially respect for us, their parents. So when there is a situation where they don’t want to listen to us, it is difficult for me to just give them what they want. But, honestly, I think most of my desire to dress them nicely has to do with an innate motherly instinct that causes me to feel like I must help my children make the right choices in life. It’s the teacher inside of me wanting to help them learn how to do things well.
The dressing drama has been going on at our house for years now. I think it began when Elizabeth was only about 18 months old. She was very sensitive to the way clothing felt on her body. We would spend quite some time in the morning or the night before selecting just the right outfit for the day. When Elizabeth finally settled on what she wanted to wear and I would begin helping her put it on, she would begin flailing her arms around, yelling, screaming and crying. Someone who walked in on the situation might have thought she was having a seizure or something. I could only gather that the reason for this behavior was because what she chose to wear didn’t look or feel the way on her body that she expected it would. This happened to be around the same time when she became obsessed with Disney princesses who wear long, “twirly” ball gowns. Maybe she expected to be transformed into a princess when she dressed herself in the morning. She would often yell about her clothes, socks and shoes “not feeling right.” “Something’s not right!!” she would scream if her socks had even the slightest crease in them when I put on her shoes. Elizabeth refused to wear anything but dresses, preferably, twirly ones. No jeans, no shorts, no t-shirts. While I wanted to buy all sorts of cute outfits I saw while shopping, over time I learned to only buy her comfortable cotton dresses and leggings because anything else would sit in her drawer and go unused.
Caroline’s dressing drama developed just recently. She usually skips off into her room and pulls nearly everything out of her drawers in search of her favorite dress. When she can’t find it and begins yelling for me to help her, her sister ends up in her room also digging through the drawers. I tell Caroline that her favorite apple dress is dirty because she wore it yesterday and she launches into a full-out fit, tears running down her face. Inconsolable. I start pulling out various options for her and selling them to her like a sales girl at Nordstrom. “This is a really pretty dress. And you look so beautiful in it!” “How about this beautiful purple dress and purple pants?” She wants to hear nothing of it. After this goes on for about ten minutes, I begin getting sweaty worrying that we aren’t going to make it to preschool in time and go off about how I don’t have time for this nonsense. Caroline, who is now naked and won’t even let me put her diaper on is apparently completely unconcerned about the day’s timeline. I decide that I am the mommy and I am in charge, so I choose an outfit (a perfectly matching one, of course) and attempt to begin dressing her. Who knew a two-year-old could be stronger than a full-grown adult? She wrestles her way away from he and is now a complete mess. Elizabeth has to creep in and make it worse by giving her a smack on the back. I’ve had enough. “TIME OUT,” I say as I place my naked, crying child in her bed and Elizabeth on the time out chair. At this point I am crying because I can’t understand why such a simple routine such as getting dressed in the morning has to be so difficult. Angry, frustrated, embarrassed and feeling sorry for myself, I storm off trying to catch my breath.
Once all of us have calmed down and we finally compromise on an outfit, we then experience the same conflict as we rush to get our hair and teeth brushed and our socks, shoes and coat on in an attempt to make it to school on time. “Something’s wrong Mommy,” yells Caroline as she complains about her socks not feeling exactly right. “I don’t want to wear socks,” she says as I explain the importance of wearing socks in the middle of winter. “I can’t zip my coat Mommy” screams Elizabeth as we hustle out the door.
After experiencing this routine (or something similar) day in and day out for at least a couple of years now, I recently had a thought. What if I said, “Choose whatever you want”? What would happen if I said, “I don’t care what you wear”? Perhaps I could spare myself and my children some of the drama that takes place each morning. We already deal with enough drama every day arguing over toys, bath time, bed time, etc. Maybe we would actually get to school on time. Maybe I wouldn’t start my day off in a bad mood.
And so was born the “I don’t care what you wear” experiment. For one week in February, I let the kids choose their clothes and I didn’t say a thing about it. I cringed as they picked out mismatched or dirty clothes and wore no socks, but I kept my mouth shut. "One week," I kept telling myself. Here are some examples of what they chose to wear. Altogether not too terrible, but the mix of patterns and colors and the lack of socks made it difficult for me to not interfere.
|
Polka dot dress and butterfly pants combo. No socks.
Remember it is February and we live in Ohio. |
|
Elizabeth is getting better at choosing matching clothes.
I can even live with Caroline's choices here. |
|
I had a hard time with the stripes and polka dots together.
To her credit, the pants did have pink polka dots.
You can see they love their sparkly shoes. |
|
Here Caroline is wearing the red pants with black bows that I mentioned earlier.
Love that Elizabeth's bow is on backwards. |
When I sat down to write this entry about ten days after the beginning of my experiment, I was surprised by some of the insights I had gathered. Here’s what I noticed:
- My children were happy! The loved wearing their mismatched outfits. They felt like they looked like a million bucks! It dawned on me that allowing your children to dress themselves builds their confidence and their independence. It also enhances their creativity and their individuality.
- We didn’t start out our day arguing. Everyone was in a good mood and I didn’t feel guilty for yelling at my kids.
- We got out the door on time (or at least a little closer to it).
- By disagreeing with their clothing choices in the past, I was over emphasizing the importance of appearance. That’s definitely not something I want to instill in my daughters in this world of toothpick thin models and young girls wearing clothes that look like they are for young adults. I was also unconsciously teaching them negative ideas about materialism.
- I was reminded that we are lucky to have clothes at all. Many parents would give their right arm to have warm, well-made clothing to dress their children in. The struggles that I deal with every day are really quite insignificant in the world. So what if their clothes don't match!
So how will we move forward? I wish I could say that I will immediately change my ways and let the girls choose their clothes from now on. However, that innate urge that drives me to want to help teach them how to make smart decisions certainly will not disappear overnight. I do plan to make an effort to make our mornings go a little more smoothly, especially with baby number three arriving soon. Perhaps we’ll take turns and I will choose their outfits every other day... yeah, I’m sure that will work! Honestly, I’m not sure what will happen next, but on those mornings where I don't get my way, I do plan to keep in mind the positives that come out of my girls choosing their clothes (independence, self confidence, creativity and individuality). Afterall, they are just clothes. And let’s face it, happy children equals a happy mommy.